* cel: fix validation of expression result type
The earlier code used the proto.Equals from github.com/gogo/protobuf, which failed to compare two messages of the same type for some reason. Switching to proto.Equal from the canonical github.com/golang/protobuf fixes the issue.
* deps: remove deprecated github.com/golang/protobuf in favor of google.golang.org/protobuf
* downgrade github.com/smallstep/nosql to resolve warning pb.proto warning
First try an exact lookup like before, but if it fails, strip the port
and try again. example.com:1234 should still use a logger keyed for
example.com if there is no key example.com:1234.
In commit f2ce81c, support for multiple path splitters was added. The
type of SplitPath changed from string to []string, and splitPos was
changed to loop through all values in SplitPath.
Before that commit, if SplitPath was empty, strings.Index returned 0 and
PATH_INFO was set correctly in buildEnv.
Currently, however, splitPos returns -1 for empty values of SplitPath,
behaving as if a split position could not be found at all. PATH_INFO is
then never set in buildEnv and remains empty.
Restore the old behaviour by explicitly checking whether SplitPath is
empty and returning 0 in splitPos.
Closes#3490
This is just a convenience if using a static_response handler in an
error route, by setting the default status code to the same one as
the error status.
Cache capacity is currently hard-coded at 1000 with random eviction.
It is enabled by default from Caddyfile configurations because I assume
this is the most common preference.
* caddyconfig: WIP implementation of handle_path
* caddyconfig: Complete the implementation - h.NewRoute was key
* caddyconfig: Add handle_path integration test
* caddyhttp: Use the path matcher as-is, strip the trailing *, update test
Correct behavior is not well defined because this is a non-standard
header field. This could be a "hop-by-hop" field much like
X-Forwarded-For is, but even our X-Forwarded-For implementation
preserves prior entries. Or, it could be best to preserve the original
value from the first hop, representing the protocol as facing the
client.
Let's try it the other way for a bit and see how it goes.
See https://caddy.community/t/caddy2-w-wordpress-behind-nginx-reverse-proxy/8174/3?u=matt
* add test case for SplitFrontMatter showing issue with windows newline
* fix issue with windows newline when using SplitFrontMatter
* Update modules/caddyhttp/templates/frontmatter.go
Co-authored-by: Francis Lavoie <lavofr@gmail.com>
* make it mere explicit what is trimmed from firstLine
* Update modules/caddyhttp/templates/frontmatter.go
Co-authored-by: Francis Lavoie <lavofr@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Matt Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
* fastcgi: Add new php_fastcgi subdirectives to override the shortcut
* fastcgi: Support "index off" to disable redir and try_files
* fastcgi: Remove whitespace to satisfy linter
* fastcgi: Run gofmt
* fastcgi: Make a new dispenser instead of using rewind
* fastcgi: Some fmt
* fastcgi: Add a couple adapt tests
* fastcgi: Clean up for loops
* fastcgi: Move adapt tests to separate files
* docs: link to CEL standard definitions
* Rephrase the anchor to CEL standard definitions
Co-authored-by: Matt Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Matt Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
* caddy: Add support for `d` duration unit
* Improvements to ParseDuration; add unit tests
Co-authored-by: Matthew Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
* adding wildcard matching of logger names
* reordering precedence for more specific loggers to match first
* removing dependence on certmagic and extra loop
Co-authored-by: GregoryDosh <GregoryDosh@users.noreply.github.com>
Closes#3365
* http: Add support in hash-password for reading from terminals/stdin
* FIXUP: Run gofmt -s
* FIXUP
* FIXUP: Apply suggestions from code review
Co-authored-by: Matt Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
* FIXUP
Co-authored-by: Matt Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
While building a layer4 app for Caddy, I discovered that we need the
ability to fill a request's context just like the HTTP server does,
hence this exported function PrepareRequest().
* For `roll_size` and `roll_keep_for` directives, round up instead of down.
For example, if a user wants to be able to look back on 36 hours of logs,
but you must round to a 24-hour multiple, then it's better to round up to
48 hours (which includes the desired 36 hours) instead of down to 24 hours.
* `roll_size` had an off-by-one error that caused the size to be as much as
1 MB larger than requested. For example, requests of `1MB` and `1.1MB`
both became 2 MB. Now `1MB` means 1 MB, and `1.1MB` is rounded up to 2 MB.
An upstream like https://localhost:80 is still forbidden, but an addr of
localhost:80 can be used while explicitly enabling TLS as an override;
we just don't allow the implicit behavior to be ambiguous.
When client certificate is enabled Caddy check only last certificate from
request. When this cert is not in list of trusted leaf certificates,
connection is rejected. According to RFC TLS1.x the sender's certificate
must come first in the list. Each following certificate must directly
certify the one preceding it.
This patch fix this problem - first certificate is checked instead of last.
This can lead to nicer, smaller JSON output for Caddyfiles like this:
a {
tls internal
}
b {
tls foo@bar.com
}
i.e. where the tls directive only configures automation policies, and
is merely meant to enable TLS on a server block (if it wasn't implied).
This helps keeps implicit config implicit.
Needs a little more testing to ensure it doesn't break anything
important.
* pki: Initial commit of embedded ACME server (#3021)
* reverseproxy: Support auto-managed TLS client certificates (#3021)
* A little cleanup after today's review session
Previously, matching by trying files other than the actual path of the
URI was:
file {
try_files <files...>
}
Now, the same can be done in one line:
file <files...>
As before, an empty file matcher:
file
still matches if the request URI exists as a file in the site root.
* reverse_proxy: Initial attempt at H2C transport/client support (#3218)
I have not tested this yet
* Experimentally enabling H2C server support (closes#3227)
See also #3218
I have not tested this
* reverseproxy: Clean up H2C transport a bit
* caddyhttp: Update godoc for h2c server; clarify experimental status
* caddyhttp: Fix trailers when recording responses (fixes#3236)
* caddyhttp: Tweak h2c config settings and docs
Moving to https://github.com/caddyserver/circuitbreaker
Nobody was using it anyway -- it works well, but something got fumbled
in a refactoring *months* ago. Turns out that we forgot the interface
guards AND botched a method name (my bad) - Ok() should have been OK().
So it would always have thrown a runtime panic if it tried to be loaded.
The module itself works well, but obviously nobody used it because
nobody reported the error. Fixing this while we move it to the new repo.
Removing this removes the last Bazaar/Launchpad dependency (I think).
* httpcaddyfile: Exclude access logs written to files from default log
Even though any logs can just be ignored, most users don't seem to like
configuring an access log to go to a file only to have it doubly appear
in the default log.
Related to:
- #3294
- https://caddy.community/t/v2-logging-format/7642/4?u=matt
- https://caddy.community/t/caddyfile-questions/7651/3?u=matt
* caddyhttp: General improvements to access log controls (fixes#3310)
* caddyhttp: Move log config nil check higher
* Rename LoggerName -> DefaultLoggerName
* matcher: Add `split_path` option to file matcher; used in php_fastcgi
* matcher: Skip try_files split if not the final part of the filename
* matcher: Add MatchFile tests
* matcher: Clarify SplitPath godoc
Sigh, apparently Linux is incapable of distinguishing host interfaces
in socket addresses, even though it works fine on Mac. I suppose we just
have to assume that any listeners with the same port are the same
address, completely ignoring the host interface on Linux... oh well.
Panic would happen if an automation policy was specified in a singular
server block that had no hostnames in its address. Definitely an edge
case.
Fixed a bug related to checking for server blocks with a host-less key
that tried to make an automation policy. Previously if you had only two
server blocks like ":443" and another one at ":80", the one at ":443"
could not create a TLS automation policy because it thought it would
interfere with TLS automation for the block at ":80", but obviously that
key doesn't enable TLS because it is on the HTTP port. So now we are a
little smarter and count only non-HTTP-empty-hostname keys.
Also fixed a bug so that a key like "https://:1234" is sure to have TLS
enabled by giving it a TLS connection policy. (Relaxed conditions
slightly; the previous conditions were too strict, requiring there to be
a TLS conn policy already or a default SNI to be non-empty.)
Also clarified a comment thanks to feedback from @Mohammed90
These functions are called at init-time, and their inputs are hard-coded
so there are no environmental or user factors that could make it fail
or succeed; the error return values are often ignored, and when they're
not, they are usually a fatal error anyway. To ensure that a programmer
mistake is not missed, we now panic instead.
Last breaking change 🤞
- Create two default automation policies; if the TLS app is used in
isolation with the 'automate' certificate loader, it will now use
an internal issuer for internal-only names, and an ACME issuer for
all other names by default.
- If the HTTP Caddyfile adds an 'automate' loader, it now also adds an
automation policy for any names in that loader that do not qualify
for public certificates so that they will be issued internally. (It
might be nice if this wasn't necessary, but the alternative is to
either make auto-HTTPS logic way more complex by scanning the names in
the 'automate' loader, or to have an automation policy without an
issuer switch between default issuer based on the name being issued
a certificate - I think I like the latter option better, right now we
do something kind of like that but at a level above each individual
automation policies, we do that switch only when no automation
policies match, rather than when a policy without an issuer does
match.)
- Set the default LoggerName rather than a LoggerNames with an empty
host value, which is now taken literally rather than as a catch-all.
- hostsFromKeys, the function that gets a list of hosts from server
block keys, no longer returns an empty string in its resulting slice,
ever.
Using html/template.HTML like we were doing before caused nested include
to be HTML-escaped, which breaks sites. Now we do not escape any of the
output; template input is usually trusted, and if it's not, users should
employ escaping actions within their templates to keep it safe. The docs
already said this.
Certificate selection used to be a module, but this seems unnecessary,
especially since the built-in CustomSelectionPolicy allows quite complex
selection logic on a number of fields in certs. If we need to extend
that logic, we can, but I don't think there are SO many possibilities
that we need modules.
This update also allows certificate selection to choose between multiple
matching certs based on client compatibility and makes a number of other
improvements in the default cert selection logic, both here and in the
latest CertMagic.
The hardest part of this was the conn policy consolidation logic
(Caddyfile only, of course). We have to merge connection policies that
we can easily combine, because if two certs are manually loaded in a
Caddyfile site block, that produces two connection policies, and each
cert is tagged with a different tag, meaning only the first would ever
be selected. So given the same matchers, we can merge the two, but this
required improving the Tag selection logic to support multiple tags to
choose from, hence "tags" changed to "any_tag" or "all_tags" (but we
use any_tag in our Caddyfile logic).
Combining conn policies with conflicting settings is impossible, so
that should return an error if two policies with the exact same matchers
have non-empty settings that are not the same (the one exception being
any_tag which we can merge because the logic for them is to OR them).
It was a bit complicated. It seems to work in numerous tests I've
conducted, but we'll see how it pans out in the release candidates.
If a placeholder in the path component injects a query string such as
the {http.request.uri} placeholder is wont to do, we need to separate it
out from the path.
See https://caddy.community/t/v2-match-any-path-but-files/7326/8?u=matt
If rewrites (or redirects, for that matter) match on file existence,
the file matcher would need to know the root of the site.
Making this change implies that root directives that depend on rewritten
URIs will not work as expected. However, I think this is very uncommon,
and am not sure I have ever seen that. Usually, dynamic roots are based
on host, not paths or query strings.
I suspect that rewrites based on file existence will be more common than
roots based on rewritten URIs, so I am moving root to be the first in
the list.
Users can always override this ordering with the 'order' global option.
Either Dial or LookupSRV will be set, but if we rely on Dial always
being set, we could run into bugs.
Note: Health checks don't support SRV upstreams.
* tls: Support placeholders in key_type
* caddytls: Simplify placeholder support for ap.KeyType
Co-authored-by: Matthew Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
The comments in the code should explain the new logic thoroughly.
The basic problem for the issue was that we were overriding a catch-all
automation policy's explicitly-configured issuer with our own, for names
that we thought looked like public names. In other words, one could
configure an internal issuer for all names, but then our auto HTTPS
would create a new policy for public-looking names that uses the
default ACME issuer, because we assume public<==>ACME and
nonpublic<==>Internal, but that is not always the case. The new logic
still assumes nonpublic<==>Internal (on catch-all policies only), but
no longer assumes that public-looking names always use an ACME issuer.
Also fix a bug where HTTPPort and HTTPSPort from the HTTP app weren't
being carried through to ACME issuers properly. It required a bit of
refactoring.
Adds `Alt-Svc` to the list of headers that get removed when proxying
to a backend.
This fixes the issue of having the contents of the Alt-Svc header
duplicated when proxying to another Caddy server.
* caddyhttp: Implement CEL matcher (see #3051)
CEL (Common Expression Language) is a very fast, flexible way to express
complex logic, useful for matching requests when the conditions are not
easy to express with JSON.
This matcher may be considered experimental even after the 2.0 release.
* Improve CEL module docs
* rewrite: strip_prefix, strip_suffix, uri_replace -> uri (closes#3140)
* Add period, to satisfy @whitestrake :) and my own OCD
* Restore implied / prefix
Wrapping listeners is useful for composing custom behavior related
to accepting, closing, reading/writing connections (etc) below the
application layer; for example, the PROXY protocol.
When using the default automation policy specifically, ap.Issuer would
be nil, so we'd end up overwriting the ap.magic.Issuer's default value
(after New()) with nil; this instead sets Issuer on the template before
New() is called, and no overwriting is done.
* pki: Initial commit of PKI app (WIP) (see #2502 and #3021)
* pki: Ability to use root/intermediates, and sign with root
* pki: Fix benign misnamings left over from copy+paste
* pki: Only install root if not already trusted
* Make HTTPS port the default; all names use auto-HTTPS; bug fixes
* Fix build - what happened to our CI tests??
* Fix go.mod
It's still not perfect but I think it should be more correct for
slightly more complex configs. Might still fall apart for complex
configs that use on-demand TLS or at a large scale (workarounds are
to just implement your own redirects, very easy to do anyway).
* ability to specify that client cert must be present in SSL
* changed the clientauthtype to string and make room for the values supported by go as in caddy1
* renamed the config parameter according to review comments and added documentation on allowed values
* missed a reference
* Minor cleanup; docs enhancements
Co-authored-by: Matthew Holt <mholt@users.noreply.github.com>
This is a breaking change primarily in two areas:
- Storage paths for certificates have changed
- Slight changes to JSON config parameters
Huge improvements in this commit, to be detailed more in
the release notes.
The upcoming PKI app will be powered by Smallstep libraries.
This makes it more convenient to configure quick proxies that use HTTPS
but also introduces a lot of logical complexity. We have to do a lot of
verification for consistency and errors.
Path and query string is not supported (i.e. no rewriting).
Scheme and port can be inferred from each other if HTTP(S)/80/443.
If omitted, defaults to HTTP.
Any explicit transport config must be consistent with the upstream
schemes, and the upstream schemes must all match too.
But, this change allows a config that used to require this:
reverse_proxy example.com:443 {
transport http {
tls
}
}
to be reduced to this:
reverse_proxy https://example.com
which is really nice syntactic sugar (and is reminiscent of Caddy 1).
* httpcaddyfile: Begin implementing log directive, and debug mode
For now, debug mode just sets the log level for all logs to DEBUG
(unless a level is specified explicitly).
* httpcaddyfile: Finish 'log' directive
Also rename StringEncoder -> SingleFieldEncoder
* Fix minor bug in replacer (when vals are empty)
* caddytls: Add CipherSuiteName and ProtocolName functions
The cipher_suites.go file is derived from a commit to the Go master
branch that's slated for Go 1.14. Once Go 1.14 is released, this file
can be removed.
* caddyhttp: Use commonLogEmptyValue in common_log replacer
* caddyhttp: Add TLS placeholders
* caddytls: update unsupportedProtocols
Don't export unsupportedProtocols and update its godoc to mention that
it's used for logging only.
* caddyhttp: simplify getRegTLSReplacement signature
getRegTLSReplacement should receive a string instead of a pointer.
* caddyhttp: Remove http.request.tls.client.cert replacer
The previous behavior of printing the raw certificate bytes was ported
from Caddy 1, but the usefulness of that approach is suspect. Remove
the client cert replacer from v2 until a use case is presented.
* caddyhttp: Use tls.CipherSuiteName from Go 1.14
Remove ported version of CipherSuiteName in the process.
* Add handler for unhandled errors in errorChain
Currently, when an error chain is defined, the default error handler is
bypassed entirely - even if the error chain doesn't handle every error.
This results in pages returning a blank 200 OK page.
For instance, it's possible for an error chain to match on the error
status code and only handle a certain subtype of errors (like 403s). In
this case, we'd want any other errors to still go through the default
handler and return an empty page with the status code.
This PR changes the "suffix handler" passed to errorChain.Compile to
set the status code of the response to the error status code.
Fixes#3053
* Move the errorHandlerChain middleware to variable
* Style fix
* Fix crash when specifying "*" to header directive.
Fixes#3060
* Look Host header in header and header_regexp.
Also, if more than one header is provided, header_regexp now looks for
extra headers values to reflect the behavior from header.
Fixes#3059
* Fix parsing of named header_regexp in Caddyfile.
See #3059
The documentation specifies that the hash algorithm defaults to bcrypt.
However, the implementation returns an error in provision if no hash is
provided.
Fix this inconsistency by *actually* defaulting to bcrypt.
We don't load the provider directly, because the lego provider types
aren't designed for JSON configuration and they are not implemented
as Caddy modules (there are some setup steps which a Provision call
would need to do, but they do not have Provision methods, they have
their own constructor functions that we have to wrap).
Instead of loading the challenge providers directly, the modules are
simple wrappers over the challenge providers, to facilitate the JSON
config structure and to provide a consistent experience. This also lets
us swap out the underlying challenge providers transparently if needed;
it acts as a layer of abstraction.
This is temporary as we prepare for a stable v2 release. We don't want
to make promises we don't know we can keep, and the Starlark integration
deserves much more focused attention which resources and funding do not
currently permit. When the project is financially stable, I will be able
to revisit this properly and add flexible, robust Starlark scripting
support to Caddy 2.
This ensure that if there are multiple certs that match a particular
ServerName or other parameter, then specifically the one the user
provided in the Caddyfile will be used.
This is necessary to avoid a race for sockets. Both the HTTP servers and
CertMagic solvers will try to bind the HTTP/HTTPS ports, but we need to
make sure that our HTTP servers bind first. This is kind of a new thing
now that management is async in Caddy 2.
Also update to CertMagic 0.9.2, which fixes some async use cases at
scale.
See https://caddy.community/t/caddy-server-that-returns-only-ip-address-as-text/6928/6?u=matt
In most cases, we will want to apply header operations immediately,
rather than waiting until the response is written. The exceptions are
generally going to be if we are deleting a header field or if a field is
to be overwritten. We now automatically defer header ops if deleting a
header field, and allow the user to manually enable deferred mode with
the defer subdirective.
Paths always begin with a slash, and omitting the leading slash could be
convenient to avoid confusion with a path matcher in the Caddyfile. I do
not think there would be any harm to implicitly add the leading slash.
* v2: add documentation for circuit breaker config and "random selection" load balancing policy
* v2: rename circuit breaker config inline key from `type` to `breaker` to avoid json key clash between the `circuit_breaker` type and the `type` field of the generic circuit breaker Config struct used by circuit breaking implementations
* v2: restore the circuit breaker inline key to `type` and rename the name circuit breaker config field from `Type` to `Factor`
The fix that was initially put forth in #2971 was good, but only for
up to one layer of nesting. The real problem was that we forgot to
increment nesting when already inside a block if we saw another open
curly brace that opens another block (dispenser.go L157-158).
The new 'handle' directive allows HTTP Caddyfiles to be designed more
like nginx location blocks if the user prefers. Inside a handle block,
directives are still ordered just like they are outside of them, but
handler blocks at a given level of nesting are mutually exclusive.
This work benefitted from some refactoring and cleanup.
Before, modifying the path might have affected how a new query string
was built if the query string relied on the path. Now, we build each
component in isolation and only change the URI on the request later.
Also, prevent trailing & in query string.
This splits automatic HTTPS into two phases. The first provisions the
route matchers and uses them to build the domain set and configure
auto HTTP->HTTPS redirects. This happens before the rest of the
provisioning does.
The second phase takes place at the beginning of the app start. It
attaches pointers to the tls app to each server, and begins certificate
management for the domains that were found in the first phase.
Our new parser also preserves original parameter order, rather than
re-encoding using the std lib (which sorts).
The renamed parameters are a breaking change but they're new enough
that I don't think anyone is using them.
* http: path matcher: exact match by default; substring matches (#2959)
This is a breaking change.
* caddyfile: Change "matcher" directive to "@matcher" syntax (#2959)
* cmd: Assume caddyfile adapter for config files named Caddyfile
* Sub-sort handlers by path matcher length (#2959)
Caddyfile-generated subroutes have handlers, which are sorted first by
directive order (this is unchanged), but within directives we now sort
by specificity of path matcher in descending order (longest path first,
assuming that longest path is most specific).
This only applies if there is only one matcher set, and the path
matcher in that set has only one path in it. Path matchers with two or
more paths are not sorted like this; and routes with more than one
matcher set are not sorted like this either, since specificity is
difficult or impossible to infer correctly.
This is a special case, but definitely a very common one, as a lot of
routing decisions are based on paths.
* caddyfile: New 'route' directive for appearance-order handling (#2959)
* caddyfile: Make rewrite directives mutually exclusive (#2959)
This applies only to rewrites in the top-level subroute created by the
HTTP caddyfile.
Previously, all matchers in a route would be evaluated before any
handlers were executed, and a composite route of the matching routes
would be created. This made rewrites especially tricky, since the only
way to defer later matchers' evaluation was to wrap them in a subroute,
or to invoke a "rehandle" which often caused bugs.
Instead, this new sequential design evaluates each route's matchers then
its handlers in lock-step; matcher-handlers-matcher-handlers...
If the first matching route consists of a rewrite, then the second route
will be evaluated against the rewritten request, rather than the original
one, and so on.
This should do away with any need for rehandling.
I've also taken this opportunity to avoid adding new values to the
request context in the handler chain, as this creates a copy of the
Request struct, which may possibly lead to bugs like it has in the past
(see PR #1542, PR #1481, and maybe issue #2463). We now add all the
expected context values in the top-level handler at the server, then
any new values can be added to the variable table via the VarsCtxKey
context key, or just the GetVar/SetVar functions. In particular, we are
using this facility to convey dial information in the reverse proxy.
Had to be careful in one place as the middleware compilation logic has
changed, and moved a bit. We no longer compile a middleware chain per-
request; instead, we can compile it at provision-time, and defer only the
evaluation of matchers to request-time, which should slightly improve
performance. Doing this, however, we take advantage of multiple function
closures, and we also changed the use of HandlerFunc (function pointer)
to Handler (interface)... this led to a situation where, if we aren't
careful, allows one request routed a certain way to permanently change
the "next" handler for all/most other requests! We avoid this by making
a copy of the interface value (which is a lightweight pointer copy) and
using exclusively that within our wrapped handlers. This way, the
original stack frame is preserved in a "read-only" fashion. The comments
in the code describe this phenomenon.
This may very well be a breaking change for some configurations, however
I do not expect it to impact many people. I will make it clear in the
release notes that this change has occurred.
Allows specifying ca certs with by filename in
`reverse_proxy.transport`.
Example
```
reverse_proxy /api api:443 {
transport http {
tls
tls_trusted_ca_certs certs/rootCA.pem
}
}
```
It seems silly to have to add a single, empty TLS connection policy to
a server to enable TLS when it's only listening on the HTTPS port. We
now do this for the user as part of automatic HTTPS (thus, it can be
disabled / overridden).
See https://caddy.community/t/v2-catch-all-server-with-automatic-tls/6692/2?u=matt
This commit goes a long way toward making automated documentation of
Caddy config and Caddy modules possible. It's a broad, sweeping change,
but mostly internal. It allows us to automatically generate docs for all
Caddy modules (including future third-party ones) and make them viewable
on a web page; it also doubles as godoc comments.
As such, this commit makes significant progress in migrating the docs
from our temporary wiki page toward our new website which is still under
construction.
With this change, all host modules will use ctx.LoadModule() and pass in
both the struct pointer and the field name as a string. This allows the
reflect package to read the struct tag from that field so that it can
get the necessary information like the module namespace and the inline
key.
This has the nice side-effect of unifying the code and documentation. It
also simplifies module loading, and handles several variations on field
types for raw module fields (i.e. variations on json.RawMessage, such as
arrays and maps).
I also renamed ModuleInfo.Name -> ModuleInfo.ID, to make it clear that
the ID is the "full name" which includes both the module namespace and
the name. This clarity is helpful when describing module hierarchy.
As of this change, Caddy modules are no longer an experimental design.
I think the architecture is good enough to go forward.
